Ana wrote:..but what did she do that was that bad, from what we see portrayed in the comic?
Psychologically speaking, we could go around and around saying that neither of them did anything wrong. Actually, Ellie's reaction, to simply run away from a horrible circumstance that you didn't even want ( and, honestly, you didn't
cause ) is human in nature. Passive or no, if we're going to justify actions, then I still say that Ellie was only acting normally.
Especially for a teenager who didn't know any better.
Again, this was just a normal little girl back in a certain time period who was just acting like anybody else would have in that situation. There were ways she could have handled the situation better, but we shouldn't
expect that out of her ( any more than a court would, being that she's still a minor ). She didn't deserve any punishment. At all.
However, speaking
out of the norm, Sadako was the one who acted the
least normal, insomuch that she was doing things that were
wrong that weren't normal human reaction. Most people
would have seen that Ellie wasn't interested, especially after the "screaming at a random passerby to save her" incident. But Sadako just kept ignoring
everybody and everyone's advice and just kept pushing. She ignored the advice of who, at the time, was her best friend and the only person who cared. She ignored the advice of a man who, at least once, tried being polite and telling her that Ellie
wasn't interested. And even before that, she forces Ellie to kiss her.
The point I'm trying to get at here is that Ellie doesn't deserve any punishment, Sadako definitely does. Ellie didn't do anything
wrong, Sadako did.